24 Hour Fitness rebuilt its memberships around club tiers and three membership levels. That makes comparing it with Crunch a little trickier than it looks.

Below, we line up both gyms on plans, fees, amenities, and guest rules, using each company's own published details.

Man jogging on a treadmill in a modern gym
Cardio and strength floors are similar. Pools, saunas, and courts are where the gyms differ.Source: Pexels

How Each Gym Structures Its Plans

Crunch: three tiers

Crunch keeps it simple, with three tiers at most standard clubs:

  • Base ($9.99–$14.99/mo): home club, equipment, no classes
  • Peak ($22.99–$26.99/mo): most classes, all standard Crunch clubs, guest privilege
  • Peak Results ($29.99–$34.99/mo): adds HIIT classes and recovery perks

24 Hour Fitness: club tier plus membership level

At 24 Hour Fitness, you choose two things. First, a club tier that sets which locations you can use:

  • Sport: 90+ clubs
  • Super-Sport: 225+ clubs
  • Ultra-Sport: 235+ clubs, the full network

Then you pick a membership level that sets what you can do there:

  • GetFit: cardio, weights, and turf areas at your club of enrollment only
  • KeepFit: adds group classes, pools, saunas, and sports courts
  • KeepFit+: adds recovery rooms, body scans, premium app content, and a Buddy Pass

Price and Fees

24 Hour Fitness doesn't publish one national price list. Dues depend on the club tier and membership level you pick, so get a quote for your exact setup.

Its current KeepFit+ online offer spells out the extra fees:

  • Join fee: $1
  • Membership activation fee: $4.99
  • Annual fee: $69.99, billed 15 days after you enroll
  • First month's dues paid at signup

Crunch charges an enrollment fee of $0 to $75 and an annual fee that varies by club, up to $89. Crunch's first annual charge usually comes a couple of months after you join.

Man sitting in a wooden sauna seen through a glass window
Saunas come with KeepFit and above at 24 Hour Fitness. They aren't a standard Crunch perk.Source: Pexels

Amenities Compared

AmenityCrunch24 Hour Fitness
Group classesPeak and upKeepFit and up
Pool and saunaNot standardKeepFit and up, where available
Sports courtsNot standardKeepFit and up, where available
Recovery perksHydroMassage, tanning (Peak Results)Recovery rooms, body scans (KeepFit+)
GuestsGuest privilege on Peak and upOne designated Buddy on KeepFit+

24 Hour Fitness says exact amenities vary by location. Use its club finder to check what your nearest club really has.

How to Compare First-Year Costs

Since 24 Hour Fitness dues vary by club and level, run the same math for both gyms using your local quotes:

Formula

(Monthly dues × 12) + annual fee + join or enrollment fees = first-year cost

For example, Crunch Peak at $26.99 with a $49 annual fee comes to about $373 before tax. A 24 Hour Fitness plan with the $69.99 annual fee and $5.99 in join and activation fees would need monthly dues under about $25 to match that.

If the 24 Hour quote comes in higher, ask yourself whether you'll use the pool, sauna, or courts enough to cover the difference.

Guest Rules in Detail

24 Hour Fitness's Buddy Pass has specific rules. The Buddy must come with you each visit, show photo ID, and sign a waiver.

You can change your Buddy once every six months, and Buddies must be 18, or 12 with a parent. Their access ends if you cancel.

At Crunch, the guest privilege on Peak and Peak Results covers the gym floor and group fitness, but not certain areas like Relax & Recover or The HIITZone.

Hours

Many standard Crunch clubs run 24 hours on weekdays, with shorter weekend hours. 24 Hour Fitness says “many” of its clubs are open 24 hours, not all of them.

If you train late at night or very early, check the hours of the exact club before you sign up at either gym.

Man holding dumbbells in a dimly lit gym
Late-night training? Confirm the hours at your specific club, whatever the brand name says.Source: Pexels

Contract and Cancellation Notes

24 Hour Fitness says some memberships carry a minimum commitment and can't be canceled during it, except as the agreement allows. Monthly plans need 30 days' notice to cancel, except in New York.

Crunch commitment plans can bring an early termination fee, and month-to-month plans may need notice before your next bill. Read both agreements closely.

Which Should You Pick?

Crunch makes more sense if you:

  • Want the lowest monthly price for equipment and classes
  • Don't need a pool, sauna, or courts
  • Want access to a larger number of clubs nationwide

24 Hour Fitness makes more sense if you:

  • Swim or use the sauna regularly
  • Play basketball or other court sports
  • Want structured recovery tools like body scans

Bottom Line

Crunch is the better pick for budget training with classes. 24 Hour Fitness is better when you'll use its bigger-club extras every week.

For other matchups, read Crunch vs LA Fitness and Crunch vs Anytime Fitness, or check the full Crunch price guide.