Crunch and Anytime Fitness solve different problems. Crunch is a big-box budget gym with classes. Anytime Fitness is a smaller club you can get into any hour with a key fob.

Here's how they compare on cost, contracts, access, and amenities, based on each brand's own published details.

Row of colorful kettlebells on a rack inside a gym
Anytime Fitness clubs are often smaller, with a focus on strength and functional training.Source: Pexels

Side-by-Side Overview

FeatureCrunch FitnessAnytime Fitness
Monthly cost$9.99–$34.99 by tierAverage about $53
ContractsMonth-to-month or 12-monthVaries; some clubs offer 6, 12, 18 months
Access to other clubsPeak and upEvery member, worldwide
Group classesIncluded on Peak and upLimited; varies by club
Pools and courtsNot standardNone
ChildcareKid's Crunch at some clubsNot offered

Cost: Crunch Is Usually Cheaper

Anytime Fitness says its average membership is about $53 a month. Each club is independently owned, so dues and fees vary by location.

Crunch tiers run from $9.99 a month for Base on a 12-month plan up to about $34.99 for Peak Results. Even its top tier often costs less than an average Anytime membership.

Remember the extras. Crunch has an enrollment fee and an annual fee. At Anytime Fitness, ask your club about any enrollment, key fob, or annual charges in its agreement.

Access: Anytime Fitness Wins on Travel

Every Anytime Fitness member can use any club with their key fob, including clubs in other countries. That's rare among gyms in this price range.

Travelers with luggage walking through a sunlit airport terminal
Frequent flyer? Anytime Fitness includes access to its clubs worldwide.Source: Pexels

Crunch gives multi-club access only on Peak and Peak Results. That covers its clubs across the US, but Base members are tied to one club.

Anytime clubs are open around the clock to members. Guests, though, have to come during staffed hours and sign in with the staff.

Atmosphere and Equipment

Anytime Fitness locations tend to be compact. They're often quieter, which some people love and others find too small.

Every Anytime club has showers and bathrooms, but not all have lockers. Some offer infrared saunas, tanning, or HydroMassage beds. None have pools or basketball courts.

Crunch clubs are bigger, with a full cardio floor, free weights, and group studios. At busy hours, that can also mean more crowds.

Classes and Coaching

Crunch is the clear pick if you want a full class schedule included. Peak covers most classes, and Peak Results adds HIIT-style formats.

Anytime Fitness puts more weight on personal training and coaching, which usually costs extra. Group options vary from club to club.

Woman doing a box jump in a gym with a brick wall
Prefer structured, high-energy sessions? Crunch Peak Results includes HIIT-style classes.Source: Pexels

Discounts, Trials, and Family Plans

Discounts

Anytime Fitness says it offers student, senior, military, and insurance discounts, but each club decides whether to take part. Ask your local club what it honors.

HSA and FSA

Anytime Fitness says some members can use an HSA or FSA for their membership. You'd need a $15 virtual consult and a Letter of Medical Necessity if you qualify.

Trials and day passes

Anytime mentions a 7-day trial and a single-entry day pass at many clubs. Crunch offers a free one-day pass through its website at participating clubs.

Family and joint plans

Some Anytime Fitness locations offer family or joint memberships. Anytime clubs don't offer childcare, and kids can only work out if they're members who meet the club's age rules.

First-Year Cost Example

Using each brand's published numbers, before tax and enrollment fees:

  • Crunch Peak at $26.99 a month, plus a $49 annual fee: about $373
  • Anytime Fitness at the $53 average, for 12 months: about $636, plus any club fees

That gap of roughly $260 a year is the price of worldwide access and a smaller club. For some people, it's worth it.

Freezing, Moving, and Canceling

Both brands let each club set its own freeze and cancellation policy. At Anytime Fitness, the membership agreement spells out the cost to cancel and any termination fees.

Anytime says memberships can be transferred with no transfer fee, though dues may change at your new club. Crunch transfers are handled by your home club, and not every membership qualifies.

See our guides on freezing and canceling a Crunch membership for the details.

A Quick Way to Decide

Answer these three questions honestly:

  1. Will I take group classes at least a few times a month?
  2. Do I travel outside the US, or to towns without a Crunch?
  3. Do crowds make me skip workouts?

A yes to the first question points to Crunch. A yes to either of the last two makes Anytime Fitness worth the higher price.

Which Gym Is Right for You?

Go with Crunch if you:

  • Want the lowest monthly price
  • Plan to take group classes
  • Like a bigger club with lots of equipment

Go with Anytime Fitness if you:

  • Travel often, including outside the US
  • Prefer a smaller, quieter space
  • Want 24/7 key fob access at every club

Bottom Line

Crunch gives you more gym for less money. Anytime Fitness gives you flexibility and global access at a higher price.

Also worth reading: Crunch vs Planet Fitness, Crunch vs 24 Hour Fitness, and our take on whether Crunch is worth it.